A writer describes a weekly habit that highlights the challenges facing traditional grocers in the age of e-commerce. Like millions of others, they turn to Amazon for everyday essentials, from dental floss to garbage bags, often delivered within an hour.
This convenience has cut into grocery stores’ profits, as shoppers increasingly bypass physical stores for non-food items. Amazon’s latest move—offering fresh groceries alongside these essentials—further threatens grocers’ market share. During Amazon’s recent earnings call, CEO Andy Jassy highlighted that perishables are driving growth in same-day delivery, with fresh groceries and essentials accounting for half of all units sold in the third quarter.
The E-Commerce Giants’ Dominance
Amazon’s push into fresh groceries is part of a larger trend where e-commerce behemoths like Amazon and Walmart dominate online grocery. Walmart, with its 40% market share in online grocery, according to a Brick Meets Click report, is also accelerating its delivery services and experimenting with innovative concepts like in-home and drone delivery.
Grocers’ Reliance on Third-Party Platforms
Traditional grocers have turned to platforms like Instacart and DoorDash to stay competitive. Instacart’s Chief Commercial Officer Ryan Hamburger claims their proposed combination with DoorDash would offer grocers the scale and technology to compete with giants like Amazon and Walmart.
However, this reliance comes with risks. Both Instacart and DoorDash primarily use in-store shoppers, a model that becomes inefficient as order volumes rise. This often leads to stock issues and substitutions, frustrating shoppers. Additionally, as these platforms grow, their interests may increasingly conflict with those of grocers, particularly in areas like advertising dollars and consumer data.
Despite these challenges, online grocery sales account for one in every five dollars spent in the industry, according to Brick Meets Click. Yet, many grocers have paused e-commerce investments, focusing instead on price cuts to match in-store prices on platforms like Instacart. This strategy, while aimed at retaining digital customers, erodes margins as grocers absorb Instacart’s fees.
Grocers do have valuable relationships with their customers, which they can deepen through digital channels. Matt Van Gilder, former director of e-commerce at SpartanNash and now with NexChapter, notes that grocers have made progress in building first-party online platforms. However, the real challenge lies in attracting shoppers to these platforms, where margins are better and data collection is more direct.
Most critically, grocers need to view digital shopping as a core component of their customer loyalty and retention strategies, not just an add-on. As Van Gilder puts it, “Now we’re talking about loyalty and incorporating the platform into the overall customer journey and experience to help facilitate their buying and making it easier for them.”
Grocers’ Struggles and Tech Firms’ Promises
Amazon has faced challenges in the grocery sector, from its unsuccessful Amazon Fresh stores to its underwhelming e-commerce service. However, the company persists, and its recent addition of fresh groceries to same-day ordering appears to be gaining traction. Meanwhile, DoorDash and Instacart position themselves as allies to retailers, claiming their combined scale and technology can help grocers compete with industry giants.
Despite these promises, doubts remain about whether these tech firms can truly assist grocers in advancing e-commerce fulfillment. Concerns arise from potential conflicts of interest, particularly in advertising and consumer data, which are critical for AI-driven shopping. As grocers lag behind Amazon and Walmart in innovation, their reliance on third-party platforms like Instacart and DoorDash highlights a growing vulnerability in the digital marketplace.
While these platforms offer a quick solution to compete with e-commerce giants, they come with inherent risks.
